Search Site
Menu
Call for a FREE Consultation 973 676-1555

Preexisting Conditions in Medical Malpractice Suits

Courts apply different rules when dealing with a pre-existing condition that was worsened or facilitated by medical malpractice. If, at the time you were treated, there was a possibility that you might suffer an injury regardless of the negligent treatment, then your recovery will often be limited.

For example, assume you are having breathing problems and you go to the emergency room. The treating physician fails to properly identify your condition and you suffer a collapsed lung. If you file a medical malpractice action against the physician, the court considers whether you would have suffered the collapsed lung even if it had been properly diagnosed and you had received prompt treatment. If your attorneys can prove that the failure to promptly diagnose and treat your condition aggravated or worsened your condition, you will be able to recover damages for your injuries.

However, if the defendant proves that you would have suffered the collapsed lung regardless of treatment, then you may not be able to recover any damages. In addition, if the defendant can demonstrate that the delay was only one factor in your injuries and can also clearly quantify the percentage of damages attributable to the delay, then the defendant may only be liable for that percentage and your recovery will be limited — see Reynolds v. Gonzales, 172 N.J. 266 (2002).

It is important to realize that every medical malpractice case is different. After reviewing the unique details of your case, an experienced injury lawyer can provide you with sound advice on how to move forward.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

$800,000.00 settlement in less than nine (9) months!
In September of 2025, Phil Wiskow settled a legal malpractice case, resulting from a botched personal injury case, for $800,000.00. Most significantly, Mr. Wiskow settled the case less than nine (9) months after the client hired him. Since the client settled his botched case for over $200,000.00, the full amount of the client's recovery exceeded one million dollars.
Settled his 60 year old client’s motorcycle accident case for $1,700,000.00
In the Spring of 2017, Phil Wiskow settled his 60 year old client’s motorcycle accident case for $1,700,000.00. Frankly, the case would have settled for more money but the most culpable party only had a $300,000.00 liability insurance policy. The firm’s client, who was already disabled and receiving social security benefits at the time of his accident, sustained multiple lower leg fractures–which ultimately resulted in numerous surgeries and an above the knee amputation–when a delivery van blindly backed out of a loading dock and pinned his leg against his bike. The majority of the client’s settlement money was paid by the owner of a tractor-trailer and the lessee of the loading dock whose dangerous loading and unloading procedures blocked the van driver’s view of the motorcycle and the firm’s client’s view of the van.
VERDICTS & SETTLEMENTS
  • In the Spring of 2020, Phil Wiskow settled a motor vehicle/motorcycle accident case for the Defendant’s 1.3M policy limit. The terms of the settlement are confidential.
Our Offices
  • East Orange Office
    60 Evergreen Place
    Suite 502
    East Orange, New Jersey 07018
    Phone: 973 676-1555
    Fax: 973-675-5674
  • Elmwood Park Office
    One Broadway
    Suite 102
    Elmwood Park, New Jersey 07407
    Phone: 973 676-1555
    Fax: 973-675-5674
  • Pompton Plains
    142 Route 23 North
    Pompton Plain, New Jersey 07444
    Phone: 973 676-1555
    Fax: 973-675-5674
  • Avon by the Sea
    416 Garfield Avenue
    Avon by the Sea, New Jersey 07717
    Phone: 973-713-4667
    Fax: 973-713-1565